Wednesday, 2 May 2018

Let The Past Die. Kill It , If You Have To

X-Wing 2.0

I have to admit that I totally didn't see it coming.  It didn't fit with what I thought I could read was happening at FFG and how they thought, how they did business.  X-Wing sales were booming, the design team were busy with Legion, it didn't seem like FFG would have either the desire or capacity to tackle a full remodel of their biggest game.

Let the past die.

It's actually a pretty massive gamble for FFG, I think.  There's going to be a ton of people who are deeply invested in X-Wing over the last few years and who don't play much but keep dipping their toes into the water and buying new ships.  They're going to lose a lot of those players, who can't face the significant one-off cost of the conversion kits to use their old stuff in the 2nd Edition.  FFG need the soft reboot to 2nd Edition to open the game up to new players who will replace those who will inevitably drop out.

Kill it if you have to.

I'm partway through my series on the Six Ages of the X-Wing metagame.  I was going to cover the 3rd and 4th Ages together and that blog is still sitting unfinished in my drafts.  Right now I think I'll probably never finish that series because they've been stripped of so much of their relevance.  A lot of the reason for doing that series was not just a nostalgia trip, but also to pull out learnings from the past that players could apply to the present and the future.  That future is now virtually a clean break from the past.   

That's the only way you can become...

Why rake over the old legends, the old rivalries?  I want to talk about the future instead.

...what you were meant to be.


X-Wing Miniatures Game - Second Edition


Cost

I'm going to just grab snippets from the FFG release articles and talk around them.  Let's start with what is likely to be the most important part for most of us... how's hard is it going to hit our wallets?


If I didn't see X-Wing 2.0 coming then I certainly didn't see Conversion Kits coming.  FFG have been pretty merciless in wringing every last penny from its X-Wing playerbase and if X-Wing 2.0 was ever going to happen I didn't see much reason for them to change their ways and give us all a leg up into the new game.  I expected a game to start virtually from scratch, with incompatible models/dials/bases/dice forcing players to pay through the nose to start again.  That was basically how FFG approached rebooting A Game Of Thrones LCG into a second edition, so if it ever happened in X-Wing I expected the same.


Conversion kits are going to be expensive as a one-time catch-up purchase, but if the Second Edition game is a meaningful improvement on the game we have now, or if you play X-Wing pretty frequently, I think it's going to be relatively easy to justify that cost as delivering a tremendous amount of value for money.  I've always championed buying an FFG playmat simply because although it's pretty expensive you'll get so much use out of it that it's one of the best value purchases you can make.  I'd make a similar argument for just taking this one-off investment of the conversion kits on the chin.


There are going to be players who can't make that jump.  Either the cost is too much, or the frequency of play too low and it just doesn't make sense for them to make that outlay.  Whenever there's big changes like there are people who are going to be left out in the cold and I think it's reasonable to expect about 20-30% of the current X-Wing playerbase to refuse the transition into Second Edition.  There's plenty of time for those sorts of decisions to be made, though, so if you think you're in that boat don't kneejerk and do anything you might regret, and I'm sure FFG are going to be doing their best to persuade you that the X-Wing you enjoyed playing is only going to be better in future.


Maybe you don't need to buy all the conversion kits at once.  Maybe you just pick Rebels, maybe you just pick Scum.  Take it slow.  We want as many of you to come on the journey with us as possible.

And however much it hurts your wallet it hurts a whole lot less than having to start again from scratch with incompatible models!



Mechanics

A lot of the fundamental X-Wing mechanics appear unchanged.  We still use dials, we still have maneuver templates, we still plan/activate/action, we still have red dice and green dice.  Look at an X-Wing 2.0 dial and you'll recognise it as X-Wing, look at the stat line of an X-Wing 2.0 ship and you'll recognise it as X-Wing.


It was so similar that my initial response was that this wasn't really X-Wing 2.0 at all, it was more like an X-Wing 1.5 that patched a lot of issues with specific cards and pilots but didn't really change the game much.  This really worried me because I've always felt like those specific design issues were a result of the limitations of the game mechanics, which placed a lot of boundaries on what the designers could do.  When they'd tried to break out of the natural design boundaries (around Wave 7 onwards) it had upset the balance of the game and X-Wing had been in a bit of a slow death spiral ever since, at least from a design/balance point of view.  

Patching old problem cards without fixing the basic issues that had made them problems could prove to be be a very short term solution, and it had me worried.


Reading the articles in more depth, though, I'm happy that this is a proper 2.0.  

Some of the ways that they've opened up design space are really neat and create some great opportunities for tactical decisions.  There's extra room for designers to work in, there's extra tools for ensuring ships feel distinct from one another, and there's extra room for players to outplay each other in.

It's certainly a bit more complex than vanilla X-Wing 1.0 was, but the base mechanics are the same and I think X-Wing has long since proven itself ready to take that next step and become a more fully rounded game.

  • Red Actions that induce stress - why has nobody thought of this before?  It's so elegant, and yet suddenly it opens up so much diversity in how ships behave.  If you think about how often people have complained about Engine Upgrade on large ships, but if it had been a red Boost action on large ships a lot of that never would have happened.  Actions are no longer a binary yes/no but there's shades of grey introduced, and you can maybe do things but they're harder.
  • We've already seen an example of how they're playing with these colour codings as the X-Wing 2.0 version of Tactical Officer that's arriving in the TIE Reaper requires a red co-ordinate action to be equipped to your ship, but turns it white.  It's a simple change, but it adds a layer of depth and tougher decision-making.


  • Changes to Turrets - basically, turrets are gone.  The Shadow Caster's rotating firing arc turned out to be the testbed for the new turret mechanic and instead we get movable firing arcs replacing turrets on all ships.  The image they show of the Millenium Falcon even takes that mechanic further and seems to suggest the Falcon covers two opposite arcs at once with it's two gunners.  You can see that the Falcon's primary firing arc isn't shaded in at all so it seems like the Falcon's only going to be able to fire from those two opposing arcs, which will make positioning the Falcon AND flying against it particularly tricky!
  • Many people hated how turrets worked.  I wasn't personally one of them - I felt like there was more problems with specific turret cards (like TLT and Outrider HLC) than with the fundamental mechanics - but it's not a hill I care enough about to bother dying on.  For a whole load of people this change alone is reason to buy into 2.0!


  • Linked Actions - one upgrade I've seen notably missing so far is Push The Limit.  I HATE Push The Limit, because it's so damn good that it dominates the EPT slot and often defines which ships are good or bad simply by whether they have a dial that can support Push The Limit or not.  In X-Wing 2.0 it seems like Push The Limit is being partially replaced by these Linked Actions on a ship's action bar: perform X then do Y.

  • We can see some examples of this on the new Dengar's pilot card, with his Focus and Target Lock actions both allowing him to chain moving his Shadow Caster-style arc around (as a red action).  These linked actions are a great way to even further separate how different ships behave from one another.  You might previously have had three ships that could all Barrel Roll and were all very similar, and now in X-Wing 2.0 one of them has Barrel Roll, one of them has a red Barrel Roll, and one of them can take a Focus token then perform a Barrel Roll as a linked action.  

  • Force Upgrade with Limited Charges - it's not just the introduction of the Force tokens that bring the idea of limited resources to X-Wing, but it's how a lot of other upgrade cards are being designed as well.  We can see a lot of that here on the example Luke Skywalker the article laid out...


  • So Luke has two Force Charges to spend during the game.  They explain that these can be used to flip a dice result in your favour at any point.  We also see that Luke's pilot ability allows him to recharge his Force charges, and combined this means Luke potentially works quite a lot like his original version - instead of his old pilot ability flipping a dice in his favour he recovers a Force charge that he can use to flip a dice in his favour.  We can also see from Instinctive Aim (the new Deadeye) that he can spend a Force charge to ignore having to spend a Target Lock to fire his Proton Torpedoes.  So the Force charges are a dynamic resource he has to decide how to manage through the game, which is more interesting and skillful than having abilities that are either on/off.

  • But we can also see that Luke is equipped with R2-D2 and Proton Torpedoes, and both of those cards have Energy charges that dictate how often they can be used during a game.  R2-D2 can regenerate 3 shields over a game, Proton Torpedoes can be fired twice 

  • And there's a fantastic example of how these limited Charges are going to be used to create a more dynamic playing environment in the new Elusive EPT.  Elusive recharges these limited Energy charges when you perform a red maneuver.  Red maneuvers are you flying your ship to its limits so it makes sense that's where you get sent to if you're evading incoming fire.  

  • What I like about these limited charges is that they mean the game state changes.  In X-Wing 1.0 we've seen plenty of examples where a game state can be quite static - if your ship struggles to deal damage against Luke Skywalker with R2-D2 because he can flip a focus to an evade then regenerate a shield, then it's always going to struggle to do so.  In X-Wing 2.0 that game state changes as players use up their charges and you'll get stuck in 'unwinnable' situations a lot less often.




Squad Building

One of the most unexpected changes is that there's no points costs at all on any of thse cards, with most of the advanced squad building being run via an app.  This means with FFG can dynamically control what ships/upgrades are available at any point in time, and are able to amend points costs.  



The days of a pilot or upgrade costing a set number of points appears to be gone, as it sounds like value is going to be affected by other things on your ship or in your squad, as well as being changed over time by FFG as they try to balance the game and stop particular things from dominating.  How frequently will prices change?  Will they change a lot of prices or just the odd one or two?  Who knows.



I'm lukewarm on this change, personally.  I can see how it could be used beneficially to shake things up in the game but I hope it remains easy to use doesn't just devolve to a lot of unnecessary meddling for meddling's sake.  I'm not keen that I won't be able to mentally squadbuild without having to crack out the app to find out what things cost, or that I can try to build a squad that should work only to have an upgrade change in price because of other things in the squad.


I'm a bit of a technophobe.  I don't like apps.  This idea just makes me a bit uneasy.  


On the flipside, though, I LOVE the 'Quick Build' rules and Threat Level idea.  


This really makes the game super-accessible to new players and I strongly hope that a lot of store level tournaments use Quick Build rules instead of the app because that would remove a significant barrier to entry.  Having to accurately gauge the power level of all your pilots and upgrades to create a strong squad was just throwing an extra hurdle in front of new players trying to graduate into the game when they should have been able to just jump in and play.  Quick Build solves that.

Quick Build moves the focus further from squadbuilding and back into what happens on the table and how you fly them.  It should be a very skill-intensive format that tests your flying and decision making to the limit.  

I very much hope that we see Quick Build used occasionally to break up tournament formats and prevent things from getting stale.


The Nitty Gritty

And finally, I'm just going to lay out some of the card fans and talk about some of the things that we can learn about the new edition of the game from them.



There's something really important in how they're treating the Fang Fighter - red dice inflation appears to be getting reined in a bit!  The old Fenn Rau would get into range 1 and with Fearlessness he could be rolling 6 hits.  The new Fenn Rau still gets an extra red dice but Fearless only helps him to reroll it rather than adding even more on top.

This is a big deal.  Red dice inflation was an unwanted consequence of X-Wing's balance being lost after Wave 7/8.  The likes of Soontir Fel's defenses got so strong that the designers had to throw more red dice at them just to punch through.  Indications that the red dice in X-Wing 2.0 are being pulled back down to a more balanced state is extremely welcome.  I also understand that Evade tokens have been similarly changed, and now change a dice result to an Evade rather than adding a whole new Evade dice result on top of your existing dice roll.



The TIE Phantom and TIE Advanced show something else that's quite important, which is that titles and unique ship abilities have been moved onto the ship itself and away from being upgrades.  This is further evidence of how much the designers are working to create unique characteristics for each ship.

Oh, and did you notice the Reinforce action on the Decimator?  Or the red Coordinate action?  Or that it's arc icon on the pilot ability is a half moon, not a single arc?



The TIE Fighter card fan highlights two EPTs that take advantage of another mechanic that's now common across all ships.  If you've not noticed yet then every ship base has the 'Bullseye' arc lines as well as it's usual front arc marked out.  I've not seen any indication that the bullseye arc has properties of it's own, the way that the Kimogila's prevented dice mods being used, but it's clearly being picked up by upgrade cards and used to generate effects like Crack Shot and Marksmanship.  That's nice because it returns more emphasis to the details of positioning and getting your opponent lined right up for the kill!


Fight To Save What You Love

I was cautious about X-Wing 2.0, but it's hard to ignore the rising excitement.  I like almost everything about it - I like the mechanics changes, I like the removal of old problems, I like the opportunity to give old forgotten ships a new lease of life without waiting for some hokey upgrade patch, I like splitting the Empire and First Order into two factions, I like the new turret implementation.



There's very very little I don't like.  Yes there's a conversion cost, but I think it's reasonable value if you're going to play X-Wing a decent amount of the time.  By one nagging concern is that... this is just where it starts, this is the baseline and we grow from here.  In the past X-Wing has grown partly through FFG holding players to ransom with more powerful 'must-have' pilots, ships and upgrades.  Will that change going forwards?  How much will we get to enjoy and explore all the fantastic possibilities of having over FIFTY new ships thrown at us at once, before new expansions and power creep just leave them all back gathering dust on a shelf?


Uncertain, the future is but I think there is A New Hope.  

September can't come soon enough!



11 comments:

  1. I think this will be more of a mixed bag than FFG thinks. You'll pull in some new players (or maybe old players that left) and you'll see established players leave.
    As for me, I'm probably not going to make the jump. The cost of bringing my current X-Wing collection into the new format is too high for my tastes, and going faction specific (for me) reduces the "freshness" of the game.
    Our weekly X-wing league (12-20 players) was discussing this last night and the overwhelming response was negative. We'll probably continue to play on as a First Edition only league.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the idea is to shake the meta up though. Pilots like Quickdraw + The Quiz are from two different eras, yet see come to the table together quite often. Both are fantastic pilots, but should characterized by their faction. Now instead of seeing the same Imp Aces over and over again, you're going to have to put together a faction specific group that may have pilots we dont use anymore or havent seen at all. Seems fresh to me.

      In my community we've got a few people leaving as well, mostly due to cost though. I think we're looking at a change that is better for the game as a whole, since competitively its been stale since wave 8.

      Delete
    2. This strikes me as the first step down the same path that 40k has taken, i.e. picking a faction and running with it. Right now, I may play several months as Rebels with lists that mix and match from Rebels and Resistance; and when I get tired of that I might run triple Defenders for awhile. That's what I meant by fresh, not getting locked into faction specific lists. Lets say that you want to run Resistance in 2.0. Cool, as of today your choices are T-70, Poe T-70, new Falcon, Resistance bomber... 4 ships? That's going to get boring pretty fast. (And yes, I get that you can buy and run multiple factions).

      Our League probably took Fly Casual to the far end of the spectrum. The other night we had a battle that involved two guys both fielding HWK's in their lists. There were quite a few comments about how long it had been since anyone had used an HWK, let alone seeing two on the same table. But, our group is known for not chasing the meta cheese. It isn't uncommon for us to give someone in our group a hard time if they bring a list that looks remotely meta. Long story short, we aren't chasing the competitive scene because there is a shop across town that is one of the playtest stores for FFG on all new X-Wing releases, and they have at least two, possibly three, guys that place at Worlds every year. Store tourneys over there are nothing but 40 people playing mirror lists of whatever the latest hotness is.

      On a more technical note, I haven't really seen anything in the new version that fixes some of the problems of OT X-Wing. One of the new mechanics is that you cannot use an evade token to increase your evade value above whatever is listed on the ship card. So, a TIE Interceptor gets hit with a proton torpedo that manages to land all four hits. If the TIE Interceptor took an evade token and then rolls three natural evades, too bad, you're still going to take a hit. I know that is rare, but it CAN happen in current X-Wing. 2.0 removes the possibility and changes the base mechanic to damage mitigation, and we already have a Star Wars game for that. It's called Armada.

      Delete
  2. Great write up, David. I understand your comment concerning your Six Ages of X-Wing series, and that the purpose of the series was to not only discuss the past, but also discussing the takeaways for the future. I realize that the announcement of 2.0 has perhaps diminished the need for this series, but I would argue that it is still worthwhile. As a new-ish player, I have really enjoyed learning about the game's history through this series. I have been checking back frequently, hoping to read the latest installment. Thanks for all the work you do, and if you ever do decide to continue the series, know that there are a few of us who would gladly read!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also agree with this, and in fact it could be an interesting piece further down the future. I started about 3 years ago and it has been interesting to see the game evolve all over the place. I like your analysis (and blog in general) and it is a good read.

      Delete
    2. I also would like to read the other age of X-Wing. They may help us to understand the new mechanics of X-Wing 2.0. I.e. they change the turret mecanism, because of TLT (age 2) and one of our analysis point out that the average angle arc is larger than 180° in the competitive meta for some time now.
      Yes 2.0 is the new future but I see it as the 7th age, which evolves from the 6 older. The purpose of your serie of blog (explain the actual meta and how X-wing evolves) is even more usefull now.

      Delete
  3. Thanks for the blog! Has helped me make sense of all the data download I've had today!

    To follow up from Mr Smith, the Bristol based players seem mostly stoked by this. I'm in.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Personally I am very excited about this second edition. It will be great to see some if the classic ships (x wings, interceptors etc.) back on the table again.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great write up on the 2.0 changes, I do hope you'll continue the Six Ages of X-Wing series though! There is a lot of time until 2.0 launches and they've been fascinating reading so far.

    ReplyDelete